Big Marketing Campaign Automation Blunders (And How To Avoid Them)

March 20, 2014

The evolution of marketing technology has evolved to an astonishing degree, providing marketers the tools to reach their audience in a single, automated swoop. Marketing automation technology nowadays empowers marketers to communicate with their global network of potential and existing customers; the dynamic puissance of a simple automated campaign is boundless, organizationally impactful, yet also extremely dangerous.

Unlike most technology, marketing automation offers no CTRL-Z option, no “undo” button. That’s why it’s essential to execute correctly on the first time to avoid embarrassing campaign mishaps. Having partnered with dozens of marketing teams over the past five years at Bluewolf, I've encountered many instances of  campaigns gone wrong -- and helped implement creative processes to fix them. Here are some highlights from my journey, along with key pieces of advice I’ve gathered along the way:

No quality assurance process for segmentation

One of the most common marketing automation blunders is sending out an event invite to non-invitees. I've spoken to marketing teams that have sent invitations to their entire database to private steak dinners. If the invite should go out to eight guests, but 7000 addresses appear in your list, you know that you’ve done something wrong, or you're planning to pick up the tab for one extraordinary feast.

An easy way to determine if a campaign segment is correct is to cross-reference its size against another list, such as the previous successful send list. At Bluewolf, we advise our clients to take campaign planning seriously; we encourage them to map out expectations and goals offline, outside of the marketing automation tool, so that numbers are not skewed by possible bad data. Lists can also be pulled from an integrated CRM such as Salesforce. Not to say that all segments should be pulled straight from CRM, but there's no harm in running a manual comparison every now and then. 

“I'm sorry Mr. Jackson”: incorrect personalization

All marketing automation tools offer some functionality to make a mass email look personally tailored to each recipient. Research shows that adding personalization to emails can improve response rates -- hence, many companies have adopted this practice. However, it’s essential to note that most companies have bad data. That is the reality for most marketers today. We have the tools to create sophisticated campaigns, but everything we do depends on data. As such, an incorrect use of personalization can destroy relationship with a customer in an instant. 

This is our sandbox!

When working in a test environment or “sandbox” of a marketing automation tool, make sure that no emails are sent automatically. Needless to say, emails containing test content such as "This is our sandbox!!" and "We'll save you money, yo!" should never see the light of day. Here are some suggestions for safe sandbox marketing automation handling:

  • Corrupt all email addresses. Typically, data tools can be leveraged to deploy mass updates. Otherwise, export a list of all your valid email addresses and append test to all of them. Then re-import them back into the MA tool as an update. This way, if an email does get sent out, a test account somewhere will receive it instead of a actual contact.
  • Add a rule to your “exclude list” to exclude all contacts where email address contains "*@*". This means that any email address containing “@” (which is all of them) will be blocked, thereby safeguarding you from embarrassing email deployments.
  • Always have a second pair of eyes check your work.

Active senders

Aside from standard personalization of email content, many companies like to dynamically send emails from a contact owner, or someone who owns that particular relationship. This is a great process to implement, as people are more likely to respond to emails from someone they know. Often a simple token can be used in the Sender fields to dictate which email address should display as the sender. Once fully implemented, emails will appear to be sent from an individual, thus boosting personalization.
 
Like most automated things, there are risks that need to be taken into account. Risks can be mitigated through iterative approaches to enhancements or a marketing organization will need to take into consideration all the many use cases where you wouldn’t want an email to be sent from that same individual. Here are a couple we’ve seen over time:
  • Active employees only!

    When employees leave your company, make sure you have a program in place to removes them from campaigns, so that your automation tool does not send emails on their behalf to prospects. This is not only confusing for the prospect, but also makes your marketing efforts look foolish.
  • Never email from the grave

    Might seem obvious, but I’ve seen campaigns go out from people that not only left the company, but have actually checked out…for good. Again, create a sync between your employee database and your marketing automation tool to prevent this blunder. This situation is awkward to say the least; make sure your dynamic senders are not only active but, alive.
  • "Marketo Admin sent you an email!"

    It’s very common for certain records to be owned by an administrative user or an internal group email address. You need to be sure that dynamic senders are real people (with real names!) who are capable of responding promptly if a prospect replies. So put a global rule in place that states something along the lines of:



    If record owner equals Admin, Operations, Donald Duck, or Michael Scott, send email from {some name that makes sense}
At Bluewolf, we always advise our clients to implement a dedicated sender program. This type of functionality can be integrated into another type of contact washing machine, or it can be built out as stand-alone functionality. Make a list (like the one above) of all the worst-case scenarios where dynamic senders are involved. Then, create new fields on the contact record called Sender Name and Sender Email Address. Build workflows that set values to those fields, and then add your worst-case scenario use cases as functionality that changes the values in those fields. With a solution like this, your marketing team will spend far less time worrying about who emails are sent from, and more time designing great customer experiences.
 
If you're looking to strengthen your marketing efforts beyond these marketing automation tips, download our free guide, The Three Pillars of Modern, Digital Marketing.
 
 
 

See More